Focusing on the bibliography associated with dissertation research
There are numerous elements of evaluation associated with the variety of literature:
- number of sourced elements of literature utilized
- the share of foreign sourced elements of literary works
- chronilogical age of resources of literary works used
- completeness of literature coverage
Quantity of literature sources utilized
In the last few years, there’s been a rise in the amount of sources into the listings of literature. Then now it is necessary to focus on 150-200 sources if in 2000-2001, the optimal was the presence in the review of the literature for the Ph.D. dissertation of 120-130 sources.
An artificial increase in their number may be required in all cases, when the scientific adviser draws attention to the insufficient number of sources. Additional information on approaches to increase the true quantity of sources get when you look at the part ”Problems arising into the utilization of the review and their solution.”
Share of international resources of literary works
As much as the first 2000s, when usage of literature that is foreign limited, it had been believed that the ratio of foreign literary works to your domestic literature must be roughly someone to three. At the moment, there aren’t any standards that are unified this regard. This parameter can vary quite a bit according to the theme for the work.
In the exact same time, there clearly was a propensity to raise the share of foreign works within the listings of used literature. There appeared a big amount of works, where the overwhelming almost all sources are foreign. For instance, you can find works by which you will find only 10-15 links to domestic literary works and a lot more than 150 to international authors. The look of such works is associated with the 2 styles that emerged in 2006-2007:
clinical supervisors often need dissertators to compose above all on international literary works
medical supervisors frequently give topics of dissertations which are well examined when you look at the literature that is western practically are not examined when you look at the homeland
The share of local experts into the growth of a true amount of medical areas is objectively insignificant. To start with, this concerns research utilising the latest technologies which are inaccessible to neighborhood researchers. In case of prevalence into the literature breakdown of sources to international literature, it ought to be noted within the ”conclusion” that ”the studied issue into the domestic literature is insufficiently examined”.
During the time that is same if you can find local sources in the topic associated with the work, it really is inadmissible to write an evaluation just on such basis as international literature. The complete lack of references to homeland literature always looks suspicious and raises concerns. More over, a few of the professors that are patriotic perceive the prevalence of foreign literature into the review.
In this instance, the candidate is confronted with a dilemma – whether or not to increase artificially the share of sources to neighborhood literary works or even to stake on content (if the topic is studied in foreign literary works and never studied in the home). The writer for this article is convinced that it’s inadmissible to sacrifice content with the goal of artificially increasing the share of neighborhood references. In the same time, there was a method to increase its share without deteriorating the information – here is the introduction of some maybe not bearing a deep semantic load of paragraphs.
During the present time, the presence of a lot of sources or foreign sources is an indication associated with the quality associated with work. This problem will undoubtedly be discussed in more detail in the right part specialized in the assortment of literature.
Here we confine ourselves to your remark that the question of this ratio associated with amount of domestic and international references into the review is always decided individually in line with the growth of this issue in domestic and foreign literary works.